Phones answered 24/7Portland, ME
Call (833) 490-5225
(833) 490-5225
Guide

Drying Plaster, Brick and Old Framing in a Portland House

Why plaster on lath, brick walls and old growth framing dry on a different schedule than drywall, and what proper drying looks like in a pre-1940 Portland house.

Illustration for the guide "Drying Plaster, Brick and Old Framing in a Portland House" (Portland, ME)
Short answer

Plaster on wood lath, solid brick and old growth framing hold water far longer than modern drywall and studs, and they release it slowly from deep inside the assembly. Drying them means lower humidity held for longer, air moved where the water actually is, and readings taken from the same points daily until they stop falling.

Key takeaways

  • Roughly 46 percent of Portland's housing was built before 1940, which makes old assemblies the normal case here rather than the exception.
  • Plaster on wood lath is a thick, layered, absorbent assembly with a cavity behind it, so the wet material is usually not the surface you can see.
  • Solid brick and stone hold large amounts of water and give it back slowly, which is why a wall can read dry at the face and be wet an inch in.
  • Old growth framing is dense and resists rot longer than modern lumber, but once wet it takes correspondingly longer to dry.
  • Drying is finished when readings from fixed points stop falling and hold, not when a surface feels dry or a schedule runs out.
  • Removing an old plaster ceiling is sometimes the right call and sometimes an avoidable loss, and the difference is decided by readings rather than by habit.

Why does an old Portland house dry differently?

Because almost nothing in it behaves like the drywall-and-pine assembly that standard drying schedules were written for. Roughly 46 percent of the city's housing stock predates 1940, among the oldest in the country, so the materials in play are plaster, lath, old growth framing, brick and stone.

Statewide the pattern is the same: Maine has about 23.4 percent of its 741,803 housing units built before 1940, against roughly 12 percent nationally. In Portland the proportion is higher still, and the practical meaning is that a technician walking into a water loss here should expect to be drying a wall built in layers out of absorbent material, over a cavity, against a foundation of stone or brick, in a coastal climate. None of that is unusual in this city; it is simply what the buildings are made of.

The cost of ignoring that is a drying job declared complete too early. Modern materials give up water quickly and then read dry, which makes a three-day schedule plausible. An old assembly can read dry at its surface on day three with the lath, the plaster key behind it and the framing still carrying water, and the consequences arrive weeks later as a stain that returns, a musty smell in a closed room or paint that will not hold.

What is actually happening inside a plaster wall?

Plaster was applied wet in two or three coats onto wood lath nailed across the studs, with the mortar squeezed through the gaps forming keys behind the lath. So the assembly is thick, layered and absorbent, and there is a cavity behind it holding wet wood.

Water tracks through that system rather than sitting on it. It travels down the back of the lath, along the top of a baseboard, around the keys and into the stud bays, and the wettest material is frequently a foot or two below or to the side of the stain anyone can see. A moisture map made by probing at intervals, rather than one reading at the visible mark, is the only way to know how far it went. Older plaster with animal hair as a binder holds more water again and is more likely to lose its bond with the lath while it is saturated.

The failure mode is also different from drywall. Wet drywall swells, sags and crumbles obviously. Wet plaster can look almost normal while its key has let go, so the sheet is held up by paint and friction and sounds hollow when tapped. Tapping across a ceiling and listening is a genuine diagnostic step in an old house, and a ceiling that has gone drummy after a soaking is a safety question before it is a drying question.

How do brick and stone fit in?

They are reservoirs. Solid brick walls, brick party walls between attached houses, and rubble stone foundations hold a great deal of water in their pores and in the mortar, and they release it slowly, from the inside out.

A brick wall that has stood in a flooded cellar for a day has taken water into the body of the brick and into the mortar joints, which are often softer and more absorbent than the brick itself. Drive the probe in and the readings fall away from the face much more slowly than the surface suggests. That is why these walls need dehumidification sustained for longer, and why a job that pulled the equipment when the air felt dry gets a call back in July: the wall was still giving water to the room, and the room no longer had anything taking it away.

Foundations add a second complication. Rubble stone and old brick foundations in a coastal climate are rarely bone dry to begin with, so the goal after a loss is not some absolute ideal number but a return to the condition the building held before, demonstrated by readings that have stopped moving. Where sea water was involved the wall also now holds salt, which keeps pulling moisture from humid air, and that changes the plan rather than just the timeline. Work on these spaces is listed under crawl space and basement moisture.

Is old framing more fragile than modern lumber?

Less fragile, but slower. Old growth framing is dense, tightly grained and often oversized, which makes it resist decay longer than modern dimensional lumber, and also means it absorbs and releases water on a longer timescale.

The density that protects the timber works against the drying schedule. A true two-by-eight joist of old growth stock that has been wet for two days will still be giving up water when the drywall equivalent next door has finished, and nailing surfaces, sill plates and the ends of joists buried in a masonry pocket are the slowest spots of all. Those pockets are worth special attention: a joist end sitting in brick or stone has limited air on three sides and is where decay actually starts in houses like these.

Sills and the bottoms of posts are the other place to look. In a house with a stone foundation, the sill sits where the wet masonry meets the wood, and a flood or a long-running leak loads exactly that joint. None of this means an old frame is doomed by a wetting event; it generally is not. It means the drying has to be aimed at the slow spots and verified there, which is the business of structural drying and dehumidification.

What does the drying setup look like in practice?

Water out first, then low humidity held in a contained space, with air moved across the wet surfaces and into the cavities rather than around the room. The equipment is less important than where it is pointed and how long it stays.

The sequence is extraction, containment, dehumidification, airflow, and measurement. Standing water comes out by pump and extractor, because no amount of air will remove a puddle efficiently. Then the space is closed up, since an open window in a damp coastal month can feed moisture in faster than the equipment takes it out. Dehumidifiers lower the vapour pressure in the room so the materials give their water to the air, and air movers keep a dry boundary layer against the wet surface so the exchange keeps happening.

Getting air into cavities is where old houses need judgment. Options range from lifting a baseboard and drilling discreet holes behind where it will sit again, to pulling a small section of plaster low on a wall where repair is simple, to drying through an existing opening where the plaster has already failed. The aim is always the smallest intervention that lets the wet part of the assembly exchange with dry air, because on a plaster wall the repair of an unnecessary hole is a plasterer's visit, not a patch of tape and compound.

How is it known when the drying is actually done?

By readings, taken from marked points, at the same points each day, until the numbers stop falling and hold for a day or more. A surface that feels dry and a room that smells fine are not evidence.

Good practice is physically simple. Mark the measurement points on the first day, including the wettest spot, the slow spots like joist ends and sill, and an unaffected area of the same material as a reference. Record a number for each point every day along with the temperature and humidity in the room. The numbers describe a curve, and what matters is the shape of it: still falling means keep going, flat for a day or two at or near the reference reading means done.

That record does double duty. It is how the drying decision is made, and it is also the document that answers an insurer who thinks an old-house drying schedule looks long. A wall that took nine days instead of three is not an argument; it is a table of readings. The claims side of that is covered in water damage insurance claims in Maine.

When does old plaster have to come out?

When the key has failed, when it was in contaminated water, or when it cannot be dried before growth takes hold in the assembly behind it. Those are findings, not defaults, and a sound plaster wall is usually worth drying rather than demolishing.

Three findings justify removal. A ceiling or wall that sounds hollow and moves when pressed has lost its bond and is coming down one way or another, so taking it down in a controlled way is the safe path. Plaster that was standing in sewage or in sea water is contaminated through its thickness and cannot be cleaned in place. And an assembly that cannot reach a falling curve within a few days, often because the cavity cannot be reached, is on its way to a mold problem, which is the subject of mold after water damage.

Outside those cases, removal is frequently a loss. Plaster on wood lath is an assembly nobody will replicate on a repair budget: drywall over the old studs gives a wall of a different thickness, with different mouldings and reveals, and in a pre-1940 Portland house the difference is visible from the doorway. Horsehair plaster, old trim, lath and the paint layers on them also carry an asbestos and lead question in a building this age, which is a reason to keep what can be kept and to handle what cannot through the right licensed trade.

Frequently asked questions

My plaster ceiling got wet but looks fine. Is it safe?

Not necessarily, and the look is the least reliable evidence. Plaster is keyed to wood lath, and water can break that bond while paint holds the sheet in place, so a ceiling can appear sound and be carrying its own weight on very little. Tap across it and listen for hollow areas, look for sag or fine cracking in a grid pattern, and keep people out from underneath a suspect area until it has been checked. A ceiling that has gone drummy after a soaking is a safety matter before it is a drying question.

Should the windows be opened to help it dry?

Usually not while equipment is running. Dehumidification works by keeping the air in the space drier than the materials, and in southern Maine the outdoor air through much of the year is humid enough to feed moisture back in faster than it leaves. There are cold, dry winter days when ventilation genuinely helps, which is why the decision should follow a reading of the outside dew point rather than a feeling about fresh air. The containment also keeps the dried area from exchanging with the rest of the house.

Can wet insulation in an old wall be dried in place?

It depends on what the insulation is. Loose fill blown into an old wall cavity settles when wet, holds water against framing and lath, and often cannot be dried in place at all, so it generally comes out. Fibreglass batts sometimes dry if the water was clean and they are opened to airflow quickly. Anything that stood in sea water or sewage goes, regardless of type. The decision rests on readings in the cavity and on the category of the water, not on the material alone.

Does a brick party wall between two houses complicate things?

It does, in two ways. The wall is a large reservoir that will keep giving water back to both rooms for a long time, so the drying has to be sustained rather than brief. And it is shared, which means moisture can migrate to the neighbor's side and show up there as a stain or a smell. It is worth telling the neighbor early, and worth including the far face of the wall in the moisture map if access can be arranged.

Is there an asbestos or lead issue when old plaster is removed?

In a building of this age it has to be considered before anything is torn out. Old plaster systems, their joint and patch materials, pipe insulation in cellars, and the paint layers on trim and walls can all carry asbestos or lead, and demolition is what makes them a hazard by putting the material into the air. In Maine, asbestos and lead abatement work is licensed through state environmental regulation, so that work belongs to that licensed trade rather than to a drying crew. It is also an argument for drying and keeping an assembly where the readings allow it.

This guide is general information for Cumberland County homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.

Still stuck? We pick up 24/7.

If it's an emergency, call now. For non-urgent help, send the form and we'll call you back.

Keep reading

More guides

WhatsApp